After some thought, I decided to get the original controller again and not an Xbox-type one. It is comfortable in the hand and I am used to it. It connects everywhere easily, to PC and mobile via Bluetooth without cables. The first one that came with the console developed drift after 4.5 years. If this one lasts just as long, then it's worth its money. (about €50)

After two weeks of use, I have to say it is very convenient (even though I was used to PS5 controllers). I got it for my computer (Windows 11) and it connects effortlessly (a relief for me who used to connect PS5 controllers). It seems to be sturdy and I also find it very convenient that it is powered by 2 simple batteries that are easily replaced. (they are also included).

After 2 months of use, the left joystick started to show drift. It gets stuck in vertical up-down movements. I contacted the store where I bought it and they told me that although it has a 2-year warranty, they do not take responsibility for anything. I have to submit a repair request to Microsoft myself and send it to them for repair (in Germany, because there is no representative in Greece), or take it to a shop for repair at my own expense (€20 to €50).
Next time I will buy from physical stores and I hope to have better service.

Excellent product. I had another imitation and with minimal use the keys broke. So I decided to try the original with the convenience of changing the battery to whatever type you want, and if it happens to break you just throw it away and move on to the next one. Very positive!

Very good for its price, I haven't noticed any issues so far. I will update in case of drift, but as for design, button quality, etc., it's fantastic. I have relatively small hands and it's comfortable.

very nice, good in the hand sometimes when there is no clear field with the bluetooth receiver it doesn't catch so well but it could also be the bluetooth's fault

As a controller, it is flawless, just keep in mind that these products often have drifting issues. Make sure to register it under warranty to be safe.

I was unlucky because the controller that came with the Xbox broke, I sent it back, and the one that came to me broke too, and eventually the third one broke as well, until the warranty expired.

The compatibility with Windows 10 is hassle-free.

I got it to connect with the Tesla Model Y and Model 3 via Bluetooth, but it doesn't connect. It connects normally with other devices

It does not connect with Windows 10, nor does it have Bluetooth, nor does it connect with a cable. 50€ in the trash. If anyone has a solution, please suggest it

It was very good but after about 2 years of moderate use it started to stick, first the Y and now the R1.

My white one lasted me 8 months, it fell several times, started drifting a week ago, but I think it's great for 50 euros endless gaming hours. I have ordered other items, but that didn't stop me from opening the old controller and trying to fix it.

Nice controller. The buttons make a little more noise than expected. With 2 sets of rechargeable batteries, it's just what I need

In exactly six months, the left lever drifts on its own during vertical movements, either up or down. Fortunately, the supplier provides a one-year warranty, so I hope it can be replaced. The truth is, I play quite a bit, but I also take care of my things with religious devotion, as money doesn't grow on trees. It has never been dropped, I don't neglect it or leave it dusty, and I always play with clean hands, etc. So if the damage must be attributed somewhere, it is in the construction. A PS4 controller with similar use for two years has not experienced any issues, so it is clearly a product defect.

I already had an Xbox 360 controller for PC and got this one as a second for my son.

Compared to the 360, it is somewhat lighter and with improved ergonomics, as the battery case does not protrude like on the old one.

Also, at the bottom of the sides, it has a textured surface, which helps you hold it more comfortably.

Another point where I saw improvement is the D-pad. It clicks very nicely and with more precision than the 360, as do the triggers, which require a lighter and more precise press.

Of course, I have the feeling that the build quality is not at the same level as the old one, which is truly indestructible. And many mention the drifting issue, something that will show over time.

Generally though, nice construction, comfortable, and with the crash test of the holidays coming up, its durability will be revealed.

UPDATE 17/2/2026: I'm coming back after 2 years and a bit. So far, no problems. It works like the first day and my son has really enjoyed it.

So far, I am very satisfied with this purchase. In terms of material durability, I have had it for over a year, it has fallen a few times and nothing has broken so far. The only alteration is the texture on the levers, which has completely smoothed out due to moderate use. So, I would say it is quite durable. I use it as a controller for my PC, it connects very easily with a cable, and the connectivity with Bluetooth was also very easy on both PC and mobile devices, as well as on the TV for steam remote play. I would buy it again

I simply wouldn't buy the white pen again, I got it to match the rest but it stains very easily, especially if you have sweaty hands like mine. I recommend getting a different color instead.

The left analog stick broke in 5 months and the up button gets pressed on its own. The d-pad has mediocre construction, when you press the right button with force, the down button also gets pressed. It feels nice in the hand and overall quite comfortable. I wish they made them more durable

From me, it's a no.
I have it for my PC and I have to say the following:
Yes, good gaming experience, good communication and connectivity via Bluetooth (version 4 for some reason?), good grip and feel in the hand, no one would say there is lag but there is a huge BUT when it comes to the quality of construction and durability, which I find unacceptable and very cheap. It is given that it will not withstand time and I just hope for a similar response from the company when this happens. However, the negative aspects are the batteries that need to be replaced every 30-35 hours or so, as well as the inadequate software for PC. I do not recommend it and I do not think I will choose this brand again.

I tried the PC controller and I have to say it's a very good one, worth its money. I highly recommend it without reservation.

2. This PC controller is top-notch and definitely worth the investment. You can't go wrong with it.

The purchase was made for €60, overall a decent product but with a major drawback - after 6 months of use, the left analog became very loose, resulting in drifting and inaccurate response to commands. €60 for 6 months of use is not exactly a bargain.

I had a 360 controller for years. I can say that it's much better in grip! The buttons and sticks are much superior (except for the possibility of stick drift). Finally, no more batteries. Connecting it with USB type C is a great convenience! Also, it is recognized without further programs or settings from all games and emulators!

The buttons are great for gaming, but they may not be suitable for someone who isn't a gamer.

Very good, better than any other, but excessively expensive. There are quality wired options for under 30€ (Spartan). It's not worth paying much more just to have wireless. Definitely not over 40€.

3 stars because it's VERY EXPENSIVE. I would say it's classic and everything works perfectly. I would say the best price for such a controller would be no more than 65-70 euros.

So, I've been the owner of controller 1 for a year. It's an excellent controller, but unfortunately the design regarding the LB and RB buttons is simply unacceptable. The controller "suffers" from a barrier issue with the LB and RB buttons, as it has two small plastic pieces inside that sink in to press the buttons. The result? At some point, it breaks and you can't press either the LB or the RB. Specifically, while playing FIFA, the LB button that changes players constantly breaks and wears out. The solution? Order barrier replacements from China for 0.80 cents and stock up on them to replace when they break. Other than that, it's a quality controller. I hope this helps.

He fell down 2-3 times and then started doing his own thing (the grid was annoying).
Luckily, I sent it to the dealership with the warranty and after they "examined" it, they gave me a credit (the whole amount) from the store where I bought it.

It's a well-built city controller and quite durable. I have the old version of the One S and in the 5 years that I've been using it, it developed a drifting problem in the 4th year. However, I watched 1-2 videos on YouTube and fixed it myself easily.

Update: I thought I would finally get rid of stick drift with this controller, but after about 7 months, it's drifting again. This is the 4th time I've had to change controllers for the same reason. Of course, the original and more expensive ones last longer, but 7 months without even dropping it once and it's still perfectly clean (like the previous ones). There's no excuse to pay so much money and have them break so quickly. From now on, I will only buy controllers with Hall Effect joysticks (and I will review them) because the drifting issue has become too much. You can't find a controller (regardless of brand/console) that doesn't break, and even worse, in a short period of time. If the issue isn't resolved with Hall Effect joystick controllers, I will stop playing altogether, even if it means the end of gaming and consoles. I can't keep paying for controllers (almost) after one use.