I loved this eyeliner, it's truly waterproof and makes my lashes look so pretty.

I have long but very straight "Asian" and downward lashes that do not curl easily. I decided to try it because of the hype. It did not work for me. It separates the lashes well and they don't stick together, but for my taste the result is very natural without curl or length. I generally don't like silicone brushes, because for this type of lash like mine they don't do a good job. On the contrary, the classic brushes with bristles are the most effective. At least, though, it did not irritate my very sensitive eyes (most mascaras give me a headache, yes, that sensitive!)

I always get the one in the black packaging (it's called cosmic black) and I never had any issues with lash separation, it never sticks or anything. I went to buy the black one again but couldn't find it, so I had to get this classic one here because I was in a hurry. It's the worst mascara I've ever used, it sticks, doesn't separate, ironically makes my lashes look thinner than they are, and it smudges incredibly easily because the brush isn't stable. Such a shame. Money wasted!

Amazing in the result but it doesn't come off at all, with any makeup remover method I tried. This negatively affected the skin around the eye and generally the eyelashes

It creates nice eyelashes, but even with makeup remover lotion, you struggle to take it off... it sticks a lot to the eyelashes. I wouldn't buy it again.

I bought the same product a second time to make sure it is the ideal one. It is 100% waterproof, but to lift the lashes, it requires many layers, resulting in them sticking together

It does what it says, nice big eyelashes and it made them look great, but it doesn't come off at all. I've been trying to remove it for 2 days and unfortunately, I don't want to struggle this much. Thank you

It's waterproof. 100%. You could cry, it won't come off at all. You can't call it Sky High though... It just colors the eyelashes, it neither lifts nor gives any special volume. It's for an everyday look, in the heat, when you don't want your makeup to melt. Nothing more.

Waterproof 100%
It doesn't smudge at all and makes my lashes stiff, causing them to fall out, 2 stars because it is indeed waterproof but I will be left without eyelashes

For those who are looking for a waterproof mascara, this is by far the best choice, I literally can't take it off

Guys, lashes become twice as long. Without knots and very soft! Also, it doesn't smudge easily, only with cleansing products! It's worth its money and more!

Guys, shock. Only this. I didn't have such eyelashes. Where it was found, I don't even know. The only warning for those who will try it is to have oil (preferably coconut) for removal afterwards. Micellar water won't budge it from its place.